| Scott Hogan 22:02 - Sep 16 with 2535 views | scarrow |
Signs permanently for Brum - 4 year deal |  |
| |  |
| Scott Hogan on 22:07 - Sep 16 with 2498 views | James1980 |
Are we likely to get anything? |  |
| |
| Scott Hogan on 22:20 - Sep 16 with 2450 views | nordenblue |
| Scott Hogan on 22:07 - Sep 16 by James1980 |
Are we likely to get anything? |
I doubt it... Villa bought him for around £12m from Brentford so doubt Birmingham will have paid more than that for him, the sell ons are usually on profit | | | |
| Scott Hogan on 22:39 - Sep 16 with 2392 views | James1980 |
| Scott Hogan on 22:20 - Sep 16 by nordenblue |
I doubt it... Villa bought him for around £12m from Brentford so doubt Birmingham will have paid more than that for him, the sell ons are usually on profit |
How about if Birmingham get promoted? | |
| |
| Scott Hogan on 22:47 - Sep 16 with 2361 views | 442Dale |
| Scott Hogan on 22:39 - Sep 16 by James1980 |
How about if Birmingham get promoted? |
Once a player moves on for less than a previous deal, the percentages previously usually end as deals are often ‘X percent of anything received over original fee.’
For example, Glenn Murray went for around 300k to Brighton in 2008, but he left for Palace at the end of his contract so it broke any percentages due to Dale as Brighton made no money. That he subsequently went for millions later in his career means nowt as Brighton made none of it and neither therefore did Dale.
Of course there may be exceptions and Villa may have a deal with Brentford that sees them get a percentage of anything received for Hogan, if so, we’ll get a percentage too. But it’s doubtful. |  |
| |
| Scott Hogan on 23:00 - Sep 16 with 2331 views | James1980 |
| Scott Hogan on 22:47 - Sep 16 by 442Dale |
Once a player moves on for less than a previous deal, the percentages previously usually end as deals are often ‘X percent of anything received over original fee.’
For example, Glenn Murray went for around 300k to Brighton in 2008, but he left for Palace at the end of his contract so it broke any percentages due to Dale as Brighton made no money. That he subsequently went for millions later in his career means nowt as Brighton made none of it and neither therefore did Dale.
Of course there may be exceptions and Villa may have a deal with Brentford that sees them get a percentage of anything received for Hogan, if so, we’ll get a percentage too. But it’s doubtful. |
Hopefully we included a future profits clause in subsequent contracts. | |
| |
| Scott Hogan on 23:19 - Sep 16 with 2294 views | 442Dale |
| Scott Hogan on 23:00 - Sep 16 by James1980 |
Hopefully we included a future profits clause in subsequent contracts. |
It’s been proven that we do over the years. But we can’t control it if the player doesn’t move on for a profit - like Murray. Or Hogan. | |
| |
| Scott Hogan on 12:36 - Sep 17 with 1748 views | James1980 |
| Scott Hogan on 23:19 - Sep 16 by 442Dale |
It’s been proven that we do over the years. But we can’t control it if the player doesn’t move on for a profit - like Murray. Or Hogan. |
So there has to be a continuity of profit. If a player moves for free or a loss and then a subsequently moves for a profit we won't make any on the future deals? | |
| |
| |
By continuing to use the site, you agree to our use of cookies and to abide by our Terms and Conditions.
