 | Forum Reply | Prediction League 26/27 at 18:49 14 Sep 2026
Brighton & Hove Albion 2 v Arsenal 0 Burnley 1 v Derby County 0 Sheffield Wednesday 2 v Stockport County 1 Crewe Alexandra 2 v Shrewsbury Town 0 Woking 1 v Kidderminster Harriers 2 |
 | Forum Reply | Refwatch - Walsall v Rochdale at 12:02 13 Sep 2026
There were some encouraging signs defensively, but as has been mentioned our inability to keep possession and lack of goal threat is a concern. Totally agree that we should not be in this predicament. Neither Brown or Mani will be prolific this season and that needs to be addressed ASAP. Once Hayes and our other more attacking wingers are fully fit we may have more goal opportunities. I am assuming that we are already exploring non registered players and thinking about what deals might be done in the January window. Who plays at 10 is a concern. Also it may be that we need to play with a 'false 9' to utilise our more effective players. The alternative might be to throw someone like EEL / Sherring up front at least for a part of games, to see if the ball sticks or can be won further up the pitch (not least because it doesn't look like Sherring will play at centre back). We need plans B and C especially if we concede first rather than persisting with tactics that are not working. Hopefully we get a result next week against Oldham who lost at home yesterday and by all accounts were very poor. Nonetheless it is a local derby and I just hope our boys are up for it. UTD |
 | Forum Reply | Objection to planning proposal for Bowlee at 12:02 10 Sep 2026
Exactly. When will this useless quango be dissolved? The issues raised can easily be resolved or conditioned without a holding objection complicating matters. |
 | Forum Reply | Heaven to Hell in 4 months at 11:56 10 Sep 2026
Spot on by Chaff - worrying times! Even if we improve I just don't see where the goals are going to come from. Like most of the fanbase I hope that I am wrong. |
 | Forum Reply | Prediction League 26/27 at 18:16 9 Sep 2026
Liverpool 3 v Fulham 1 Charlton Athletic 1 v Portsmouth 1 AFC Wimbledon 2 v Doncaster Rovers 1 Port Vale 2 v Exeter City 1 Forest Green 3 v Gateshead 0 |
 | Forum Reply | Ahead of the Forum.." A message from the Board". at 18:04 9 Sep 2026
My interpretation of the statement is that it is a 'vote of confidence' in IW. The board have an agreed position which will respond to 90% of potentially awkward questions or allow them to curtail debate on difficult matters. The Forum could probably not have gone ahead in other circumstances. It is really unfortunate that IW is in this position as it is largely undeserved in my view. Every manager makes mistakes but his have been magnified by rotten luck in respect of injuries and consequent selection problems. I hope he turns it around and we get 2-3 points in the next two games otherwise the decision will become a formality. On the basis of recent performances unfortunately I don't see how he will do it against two useful sides. Hopefully he gets the support in the interim from the club and players to restore some confidence. |
 | Forum Reply | Fans’ Forum at 09:44 8 Sep 2026
James- not sure that this is a good idea and would potentially open a can of worms and undermine IW making the whole situation even worse? I am of the opinion that at this delicate time the Forum could be damaging and maybe should not progress although it is a bit late in the day to postpone? |
 | Forum Reply | Refwatch - Rochdale v Gillingham at 01:46 6 Sep 2026
The responses given post match by IW were very plausible but he is now under intense pressure. As he acknowledges he needs to deliver points and the next two games are critical. Patience is a virtue but time is running out. The Fans Forum should be postponed as this could do more harm than good. It would no doubt focus on obvious errors with signings, selections substitutions etc. Sam Waller who is a competent goalkeeper surely need to relieve Ramming at the moment. As has been stated elsewhere Wilson is not ready for EFL2 football. I think we may be stuck with Sherring and Maguire. Given Mani's form we may need to play with a false No 9 and utilise wingers to attack unless we find an unregistered player. Even so we now have too many wingers. Our strength is in midfield and we should seek to utilise Adeeko, Taylor and Gilmour as often as possible in coming weeks. Hopefully others returning from injury will also help although most are long term casualties. I am not confident we do have the calibre in the squad and waiting for the January window will be too late. What has TAR done wrong not to feature in games? Given that it is early days, I do think there are three or for teams who are as poor as us therefore we should focus on our own mini league at the bottom of the table. We need to be a s competitive as possible. UTD |
 | Forum Reply | Unacceptable at 01:20 6 Sep 2026
Confidence is now at rock bottom after the second half to-day. It is fair to say we don't have leaders on the pitch. We don't have a settled team and the young defenders/loanees are not being given a fair chance to perform. Notwithstanding that I feel that Ramming and Wilson need to be dropped from the starting XI. There is some quality in the squad but not in critical positions. We do need a dominant centre back and a goal scorer. At the moment we are toothless up front despite the efforts of Brown. More than than we need clear tactics and game management with players in the right positions and substitutions made at the right times. Why Francis was not replaced at half time is a mystery and in any case I think that Gilmour and Baba are a better combination anyway. Not sure that IW is a good judge of the calibre required in EFL2 or knows what his best team is on any given matchday. Incidentally Shrewsbury were the better team against Fleetwood despite losing to-day so the performance on Tuesday was encouraging. We can get out of this mess in time but football is a results business. |
 | Forum Reply | Watson..... at 01:02 6 Sep 2026
Okay but IW needs 2-3 points from the next two games. If we loose both then there is no way back and I think he would be honest enough to acknowledge this based on his post match interview. Agree that we need to dispense of the players who are not good enough or fit enough. The management should now know who these individuals are. The injury list is unprecedented with two more out this week until December. Not sure that there are thousands out there waiting to be signed but if there is a centre back and a centre forward who can score goals then we need to try and trade. Possibly at the expense of one of our many wingers. In my view IW needs help with this as our signings this season to date have not been great. |
 | Forum Reply | Prediction League 26/27 at 12:07 2 Sep 2026
Manchester City 4-1 Coventry City Sheffield United 2-1 Norwich City Huddersfield Town 3-1 Notts County Rochdale 2-1 Gillingham Scunthorpe United 1-2 Harrogate Town |
 | Forum Reply | Refwatch - Rochdale v Shrewsbury Town at 11:24 2 Sep 2026
Just watched the highlights and pot match conference. Well done to IW and all of the players involved on getting a result which although flattering was well deserved. This team will improve over time and hopefully consolidate out position in the league, especially once the injuries clear up. Hopefully starting with a win over Gillingham on Saturday. Based on early results this is going to be an interesting league with only Bristol Rovers looking outstanding, so looking forward to plenty of entertainment! UTD |
 | Forum Reply | Refwatch - Rochdale v Shrewsbury Town at 12:20 1 Sep 2026
Under normal circumstances I would agree but IW is now in the casino gambling on signings I'm afraid due to our lack of goal threat. I guess it depends on what terms we secure Jay Bird if he is coming. I would be amazed if Mani could not score goals at EFL2 level, but if he gets no service and is feeding off scraps how is he expected to perform as a penalty box striker? Bird is a different proposition and would hold the ball up giving us possession in the final third. Hopefully if we can afford it the two of them could combine to create something more potent than we have at the moment? |
 | Forum Reply | Refwatch - Colchester United v Rochdale at 17:14 29 Aug 2026
Just listened to the game -another two hours I will never get back. Despite trying to dress the seriousness of the situation up even the Dale Player commentators sounded a bit despondent. Although on the face of it it sounded like an improved away performance where we might of salvaged a point, did we ever look like scoring? Where are our goals going to come from? Unfortunately IW looks underqualified and inexperienced at this level waiting for us to go one down late in the game before changing things. We need to be much more proactive. Worst of all he strikes me as an 'unlucky' manager based on signings and injuries to date. Not a good combination. Regretfully the pressure is on the club now and this is a massive week to try and get some points as well as somebody who knows where the back of the net is. |
 | Forum Reply | Maguire injured again... at 17:43 27 Aug 2026
If IW is bringing in 2 new players they need to be of the standard required in EFL2. I would now prefer to see some seasoned pros in key positions who are not injury prone. All easier said than done but unfortunately my confidence in our recruitment has dropped since last season. Colchester will be tough but we now need to battle for every point and a draw would look like a decent result in our circumstances. |
 | Forum Reply | Formation Conundrum - Fans Choices? at 14:53 25 Aug 2026
Looks like a much more balanced and solid formation. Surely there will be a place for Taylor in the side replacing Francis or East. Hopefully Smith will also get some minutes. |
 | Forum Reply | Prediction League 26/27 at 14:49 25 Aug 2026
Bournemouth 2 Everton 1 Watford 2 West Ham 1 Sheffield Weds 2 Bromley 0 Oldham 3 Swindon 1 York 3 Exeter 0 |
 | Forum Reply | Refwatch - Rochdale v Crawley Town at 11:49 23 Aug 2026
Having listened to the commentary and watched the highlights I think we are in trouble. IW's post match analysis did not give me much confidence and unfortunately he already looks like a man under intense pressure. losing our first two is not a catastrophe but it is the manner in which we are getting beaten. Ideally we need a minimum of 4 points from the next three games to get back on track. Otherwise the manager will be on borrowed time as we scramble for points against some of the better teams in the division. I also watched passages of the other EFL2 games before our match and do not believe that all is lost given the standard of performance on show. Bristol Rovers and Chesterfield looked like good sides. Newport performed credibly and could have snatched a draw at the death. However Salford, Walsall and Grimsby looked like ordinary sides. The thing that stood out for me was the pace, athleticism and strength of the other teams players and their desire for the second ball. Hopefully Taylor, Adeeko and Petit can help to address this sooner rather than later. Not sure that Wilson is right for us at his stage of development. Clearly systems and formations need to be sensible with players in positions they are comfortable with, but I am more concerned with the teams confidence and body language. We looked like cats in the headlights allowing Crawley to pass around us, and our defending lacks any authority which is not helped by an inexperienced keeper. They even kept three players up field at our corners such was their confidence! However my greatest concern is where are the goals going to come from? Mani is a passenger in the formation we play and Brown is anything but prolific. They are not linking and chances are not being created. Also don't think that Brown despite his work rate is a 10 and would prefer to see him as an out and out striker. I appreciate that there are no easy solutions otherwise we would simply go and buy someone like Matt Rush. However we need to address this issue now and certainly before the transfer deadline. Hopefully IW has the guile to solve these issues and turn things around as players return. We need to see marginal improvements on a week by week basis together with tactical clarity. He has a big job on his hands and admittedly has been unlucky with injuries but the squad doesn't look right. It is such a shame that the football entertainment has dipped when there has been so much good investment into the non playing side of the club. UTD. |
 | Forum Reply | Formation Conundrum - Fans Choices? at 17:20 18 Aug 2026
Watched the second half and both teams were excellent full of pace and attacking intent -it could easily have been 4-4. On a different planet to our match. Banks was good as ironically was Newby who changed the game for York. Both sides were so fluid that formations seemed to be secondary. Crawley will be difficult to beat, but we will not do it without attacking intent and a no fear attitude. TAR, Duberry and Hannant will need to be creative and hopefully provide chances for Mani, Rodney and Brown. We are shaky at the back but our attacking in the last game was extremely poor. Hopefully the squad will click this week and we see a big improvement. UTD |
Please log in to use all the site's facilities |  | Edindale
|
Site Scores| Prediction League: | 0 | | TOTAL: | 0 |
|