| Referee for sunday. 12:05 - May 23 with 2789 views | IanSouthstander |
John Brooks.
We've only had him once this season....... Our demolition of Leeds back in september.
Good omen ? |  | | |  |
| Referee for sunday. on 13:10 - May 23 with 2693 views | yateleysaint |
Let’s hope so. |  |
| You cannot reason a person out of something they were not reasoned into. |
| |
| Referee for sunday. on 12:45 - May 24 with 2499 views | SFC_Referee |
He’s one of the refs who’s heading up, so I wouldn’t of thought we’d get too many issues from him on Sunday |  |
| |
| Referee for sunday. on 14:11 - May 24 with 2466 views | TimSaint |
| Referee for sunday. on 12:45 - May 24 by SFC_Referee |
He’s one of the refs who’s heading up, so I wouldn’t of thought we’d get too many issues from him on Sunday |
Don't forget that there will also be VAR on Sunday, so Jarred Gillett could play an important role too !! |  |
| |
| Referee for sunday. on 09:58 - May 25 with 2349 views | darthvader |
| Referee for sunday. on 14:11 - May 24 by TimSaint |
Don't forget that there will also be VAR on Sunday, so Jarred Gillett could play an important role too !! |
Feels me with dred . VAR has been shocking for us in the past |  |
| |
| Referee for sunday. on 11:06 - May 25 with 2325 views | A1079 |
| Referee for sunday. on 09:58 - May 25 by darthvader |
Feels me with dred . VAR has been shocking for us in the past |
If it is a 50-50 decision or even say 55 - 45 our way it will go to Leeds Utd. The PL all the pundits, commentators etc all want Leeds Utd in the PL and not us. Plus the fact that officials will be more concerned about upsetting Leeds Utd FC and their fans than say "little" Southampton. I know I am being cynical (and it may be misplaced) but that is how I feel. [Post edited 25 May 13:04]
|  | | |
| Referee for sunday. on 12:24 - May 25 with 2285 views | DorsetIan |
| Referee for sunday. on 14:11 - May 24 by TimSaint |
Don't forget that there will also be VAR on Sunday, so Jarred Gillett could play an important role too !! |
Completely bonkers that this game has VAR.
A whole championship season without it and then it’s thrown in at the end.
The mindset that it should be used wherever possible is so f*cked up. As if those in charge still don’t get what an utter disgrace it is.
And what a game to suck the enjoyment out of. | |
| |
| Referee for sunday. on 20:23 - May 25 with 2184 views | saint22 |
| Referee for sunday. on 14:11 - May 24 by TimSaint |
Don't forget that there will also be VAR on Sunday, so Jarred Gillett could play an important role too !! |
Oh dear he is another incompetent fool | | | |
| Referee for sunday. on 07:20 - May 26 with 2084 views | darthvader |
| Referee for sunday. on 11:06 - May 25 by A1079 |
If it is a 50-50 decision or even say 55 - 45 our way it will go to Leeds Utd. The PL all the pundits, commentators etc all want Leeds Utd in the PL and not us. Plus the fact that officials will be more concerned about upsetting Leeds Utd FC and their fans than say "little" Southampton. I know I am being cynical (and it may be misplaced) but that is how I feel. [Post edited 25 May 13:04]
|
I think you are spot on .
I dont want to say what i feel about it out loud because i dont want to jinx it .
Its almost like we barely exist to many sky /tv/YouTube pundits .
They will be looking to find a way to get them through so we have to be perfect | |
| |
Login to get fewer ads
| Referee for sunday. on 23:52 - May 26 with 1884 views | SFC_Referee |
Well tbf to the offials for this game, they officiated well with minimum controversy and VAR went pretty unnoticed with no interventions or delays. So a pretty decent day for the officials to this game | |
| |
| Referee for sunday. on 23:53 - May 26 with 1882 views | saint22 |
| Referee for sunday. on 23:52 - May 26 by SFC_Referee |
Well tbf to the offials for this game, they officiated well with minimum controversy and VAR went pretty unnoticed with no interventions or delays. So a pretty decent day for the officials to this game |
I wouldn’t say that
He gave some dubious decisions both ways and should have shown a couple of Leeds players cards a lot earlier | | | |
| Referee for sunday. on 00:45 - May 27 with 1862 views | SFC_Referee |
| Referee for sunday. on 23:53 - May 26 by saint22 |
I wouldn’t say that
He gave some dubious decisions both ways and should have shown a couple of Leeds players cards a lot earlier |
But there’s always going to be some cautionings that people will disagree with and same for fouls, as in these cup finals if there’s ever any uncertainty it’ll most likely go the defenders way.
But the only cautioning early on I felt he missed was when Aribo had gust shirt pulled and stopped an attack just outside their box. But other than that, I thought the ref got most of the discipline correct for today | |
| |
| Referee for sunday. on 13:05 - May 29 with 1643 views | TimSaint |
| Referee for sunday. on 23:52 - May 26 by SFC_Referee |
Well tbf to the offials for this game, they officiated well with minimum controversy and VAR went pretty unnoticed with no interventions or delays. So a pretty decent day for the officials to this game |
He let too much go unpunished early on. The shirt pull on Aribo after about 10 mins was blatant and worthy of a card - regardless of what minute it was in. There was also a bad foul on Downes that looked worthy of a card, but we didn't even get a free kick. (All still a bit of a blur, so can't remember when this was !!).
I felt that he was quick to dish out a few yellow cards to Saints players, but lacked consistency by not giving cards to Leeds players for similar actions.
By far the worst decision of the day was at the very end. The Leeds defender blatantly booted Aribo up in the air, as our 'indestructible' tried to delay a free kick being taken. Instead of a red for the Leeds player kicking out, both he and Aribo got yellows. It was violent conduct and VAR should have intervened, but as it was a Leeds player and at the end of the game, they didn't bother. | |
| |
| Referee for sunday. on 13:32 - May 29 with 1620 views | SFC_Referee |
| Referee for sunday. on 13:05 - May 29 by TimSaint |
He let too much go unpunished early on. The shirt pull on Aribo after about 10 mins was blatant and worthy of a card - regardless of what minute it was in. There was also a bad foul on Downes that looked worthy of a card, but we didn't even get a free kick. (All still a bit of a blur, so can't remember when this was !!).
I felt that he was quick to dish out a few yellow cards to Saints players, but lacked consistency by not giving cards to Leeds players for similar actions.
By far the worst decision of the day was at the very end. The Leeds defender blatantly booted Aribo up in the air, as our 'indestructible' tried to delay a free kick being taken. Instead of a red for the Leeds player kicking out, both he and Aribo got yellows. It was violent conduct and VAR should have intervened, but as it was a Leeds player and at the end of the game, they didn't bother. |
Ok but there’s a reason you don’t see refs going into games waving the cards about from minute 1, as they don’t want there to be controversy and loads of discipline, so will try and avoid it as much as they can. As like I stated previously, I do agree about their lad getting a cautioning for the shirt pull on Aribo, as that should always be punished, but the rest was pretty fair and consistent (and him keeping the cards in his pocket benefited us more than it did Leeds). But the tackle on Downes I can’t recall so can’t exactly say much on that one.
But anyway, no that last incident with Aribo ain’t a red for VC, as for starters their player could argue he was going for the ball but Aribo got in the way, but even then VC needs excessive levels of force and that kick didn’t have it. As a cautioning for each player was spot on there from the ref | |
| |
| Referee for sunday. on 15:24 - May 29 with 1566 views | TimSaint |
| Referee for sunday. on 13:32 - May 29 by SFC_Referee |
Ok but there’s a reason you don’t see refs going into games waving the cards about from minute 1, as they don’t want there to be controversy and loads of discipline, so will try and avoid it as much as they can. As like I stated previously, I do agree about their lad getting a cautioning for the shirt pull on Aribo, as that should always be punished, but the rest was pretty fair and consistent (and him keeping the cards in his pocket benefited us more than it did Leeds). But the tackle on Downes I can’t recall so can’t exactly say much on that one.
But anyway, no that last incident with Aribo ain’t a red for VC, as for starters their player could argue he was going for the ball but Aribo got in the way, but even then VC needs excessive levels of force and that kick didn’t have it. As a cautioning for each player was spot on there from the ref |
Leeds had a free kick in about the 100th or 101st minute.
Yes Aribo was standing too close to the ball to waste time, but that does not give the Leeds player the right to take 1 step and kick our man. He deliberately missed the ball (from a very close) to kick Aribo. I get he was frustrated and lost his temper because Leeds had basically lost at that stage, but it was deliberate. If he did that it the Prem, he would have got a straight red for violent conduct. VAR should have intervened.
But hey, who really cares anyway. It was at the end of the game, it didn't change the outcome and we won !! :-) | |
| |
| |
By continuing to use the site, you agree to our use of cookies and to abide by our Terms and Conditions.
