| Everton done a clint hill 21:45 - Sep 17 with 2660 views | loftboy |
At least a foot over the line, disgracefull |  |
| |  |
| Everton done a clint hill on 21:46 - Sep 17 with 2060 views | Hayesender |
Same lino ain't it? |  |
| |
| Everton done a clint hill on 22:05 - Sep 17 with 2006 views | Watford_Ranger |
If that was at least 12 inches then your missus is fibbing  |  | | |
| Everton done a clint hill on 22:10 - Sep 17 with 1984 views | loftboy |
I was counting the far side of the ball as well  | |
| |
| Everton done a clint hill on 22:12 - Sep 17 with 1972 views | Northernr |
Same linesman from the Ashley Young incident at Old Trafford last year.
No doubt back in the Premiership next week. |  | | |
| Everton done a clint hill on 22:12 - Sep 17 with 1971 views | Juzzie |
It wasn't as clear cut as Clint's but it was over. Enthralling end to the game.
|  | | |
| Everton done a clint hill on 22:24 - Sep 17 with 1937 views | Jamie |
| Everton done a clint hill on 22:12 - Sep 17 by Northernr |
Same linesman from the Ashley Young incident at Old Trafford last year.
No doubt back in the Premiership next week. |
Quite clearly onside. | | | |
| Everton done a clint hill on 22:39 - Sep 17 with 1908 views | westolian |
| Everton done a clint hill on 22:24 - Sep 17 by Jamie |
Quite clearly onside. |
Deceptive angle and quite clearly 6 playing him onside |  |
| I've found a team sheet for the weekend - anyone interested ? |
| |
| Everton done a clint hill on 23:25 - Sep 17 with 1839 views | daveB |
i thought the fellani offisde was worse than the disallowed goal which is always tough to see |  | | |
Login to get fewer ads
| Everton done a clint hill on 23:36 - Sep 17 with 1821 views | smegma |
| Everton done a clint hill on 22:39 - Sep 17 by westolian |
Deceptive angle and quite clearly 6 playing him onside |
Its ok , the lino was playing Young onside. | | | |
| Everton done a clint hill on 23:48 - Sep 17 with 1813 views | QPR1882 |
| Everton done a clint hill on 22:24 - Sep 17 by Jamie |
Quite clearly onside. |
What everyone fails to notice is there are only 9 QPR players visible in this shot,the 10th outfield player is having a chat with the keeper and is oblivious to the danger Young is putting us under.
100% not offside and apologies to the officials for thinking young was. |  | | |
| Everton done a clint hill on 00:01 - Sep 18 with 1799 views | QPR1882 |
 | | | |
| Everton done a clint hill on 00:03 - Sep 18 with 1796 views | RBlock |
| Everton done a clint hill on 22:39 - Sep 17 by westolian |
Deceptive angle and quite clearly 6 playing him onside |
It is the way they are all leaning... |  | | |
| Everton done a clint hill on 08:05 - Sep 18 with 1712 views | Walnut |
| Everton done a clint hill on 00:03 - Sep 18 by RBlock |
It is the way they are all leaning... |
Not forgetting its the same bloke that gave Man City a corner the other week when it was clearly our goal kick & what do you know, City scored from that passage of play | | | |
| Everton done a clint hill on 09:15 - Sep 18 with 1640 views | Michael_Hunt |
Looking at the decision I believe the lino could actually have a case to say that the WHOLE of the ball didn't cross the line, albeit by a few mm. |  | | |
| Everton done a clint hill on 09:25 - Sep 18 with 1632 views | pomanjou |
| Everton done a clint hill on 09:15 - Sep 18 by Michael_Hunt |
Looking at the decision I believe the lino could actually have a case to say that the WHOLE of the ball didn't cross the line, albeit by a few mm. |
You are right. As a guest of NUFC at Everton we were as one in thinking we had stolen a point.
Fact is until they allow the technology to decide (for good or bad and it is not 100% perfect) peeps are not going to be satisfied. And I suppose that when it does come in the peeps will harp back to the old days when it would/would not have been allowed. Never satisfied.
Persoanlly I dont believe Pardew should get the plaudits for clever management but should be pilloried for not starting with Ba which may have won them the game. |  |
| |
| Everton done a clint hill on 12:11 - Sep 18 with 1563 views | Clive_Anderson |
Doesn't look over the line to me. Some of the ball is in shadow on the left and that part isn't entirely over the line.
Either way it's a pretty difficuly call for the linesman. | | | |
| Everton done a clint hill on 12:17 - Sep 18 with 1549 views | Mildo25 |
| Everton done a clint hill on 12:11 - Sep 18 by Clive_Anderson |
Doesn't look over the line to me. Some of the ball is in shadow on the left and that part isn't entirely over the line.
Either way it's a pretty difficuly call for the linesman. |
I thought the same. Given the speed of the incident I'd say that it is impossible for the linesman to be 100% sure. From memory the goal should only be given if the officials are 100% sure? I can't really blame the officials in this case! |  | | |
| Everton done a clint hill on 12:19 - Sep 18 with 1542 views | Northernr |
Give over, it's a goal, simple as. | | | |
| Everton done a clint hill on 12:21 - Sep 18 with 1534 views | Clive_Anderson |
| Everton done a clint hill on 12:19 - Sep 18 by Northernr |
Give over, it's a goal, simple as. |
Look at the shape of the ball in the picture. It ain't round. | | | |
| Everton done a clint hill on 12:23 - Sep 18 with 1528 views | Northernr |
| Everton done a clint hill on 12:21 - Sep 18 by Clive_Anderson |
Look at the shape of the ball in the picture. It ain't round. |
I've looked at the shape of the ball in the picture and it's still a goal. | | | |
| Everton done a clint hill on 12:25 - Sep 18 with 1523 views | Clive_Anderson |
| Everton done a clint hill on 12:23 - Sep 18 by Northernr |
I've looked at the shape of the ball in the picture and it's still a goal. |
If any of the ball is overhanging even a small part of the line then it isn't over.
The shadowed part of the ball looks behind the goalpost from that angle. | | | |
| Everton done a clint hill on 12:27 - Sep 18 with 1520 views | Northernr |
| Everton done a clint hill on 12:25 - Sep 18 by Clive_Anderson |
If any of the ball is overhanging even a small part of the line then it isn't over.
The shadowed part of the ball looks behind the goalpost from that angle. |
It doesn't in my opinion, but it's pointless continuing with this.
I said it was a goal straight away at normal speed, said it was a goal on the first replay, saw it was a goal on the freeze frame and it's a goal in that picture as well IMO. [Post edited 1 Jan 1970 1:00]
| | | |
| Everton done a clint hill on 12:35 - Sep 18 with 1501 views | Clive_Anderson |
| Everton done a clint hill on 12:27 - Sep 18 by Northernr |
It doesn't in my opinion, but it's pointless continuing with this.
I said it was a goal straight away at normal speed, said it was a goal on the first replay, saw it was a goal on the freeze frame and it's a goal in that picture as well IMO. [Post edited 1 Jan 1970 1:00]
|
Fair enough if you made your mind up straight away.
Here's how it looks to me anyway:
 [Post edited 1 Jan 1970 1:00]
| | | |
| Everton done a clint hill on 12:48 - Sep 18 with 1469 views | Mildo25 |
I think the conclusion is that even with replays from multiple angles, freezeframes etc, people are still disagreeing. Until we give officials tv replays, goal line technology etc. we are always going to get wrong / dubious decisions. Sure they make some really blatent mistakes, but sometimes they have an impossible job. | | | |
| |
By continuing to use the site, you agree to our use of cookies and to abide by our Terms and Conditions.
