| Best squad in years. 19:39 - Nov 21 with 3642 views | Bobbi66 | Very few weaknesses in the team,players coming on are just as good.quite confident for the season. |  | | |  |
| Best squad in years. on 17:06 - Nov 22 | Superhoops2808 |
| Best squad in years. on 22:29 - Nov 21 by StreathamRanger | Best manager in years. Best since Warnock. |
And to think many in the summer were saying it would not have been a disaster if he had gone |  | |  |
| Best squad in years. on 17:12 - Nov 22 | DannytheR |
| Best squad in years. on 16:11 - Nov 22 by JamesB1979 | I don’t think the post was saying we are the best squad / side in the league. We were saying this is best squad in years. I think that’s pretty fair. We seem to be a team fully capable of competing for the playoffs. That’s a big improvement. We’ve been in the league since 15/16. Which squads have been better than this one? We’re not good enough to compete for automatics but I think we can be competitive against all sides. Again this all is meaningless if we don’t keep the squad fit. |
It's an interesting one. Absolutely wouldn't dispute the squad depth is better than it has been for donkey's years. At the risk of nitpicking, though, I'd also say we've had an unusual amount of money available because of the Eze sell-on. (Which we've spent smartly.) And we've also needed the squad more than in the past, because for whatever reason, our injury record has been worse than at any point in recent memory. I suppose the wider question is how much a squad is about depth and how much the quality of the key players. Because that first pre-Covid Warburton team had Chair/Osayi Samuel/Eze/Wells as the front four, and I think the only one of the current forwards as good as that is still Chair! (I like Burrell and Kone but Wells was better than either, Poku is about on a level with BOS but the latter never got injured, and Eze was Eze.) And then with the later Warbs team, again, you had the best versions of Dieng, Dickie and Barbet, Illy and Willock on fire, a fit and motivated Johansen and Austin. (That Rangers vs this one would be a genuinely interesting game.) Anyway, as I say, wasn't disputing the original post as much as agreeing with Antii's that we still feel some way from the finished article. The squad feels deeper now for sure, and we seem solid in a way we haven't for a long time. But there were also times (however fleeting) under Warburton and even Beale when you'd have backed us to turn anyone over in the league, and I'm not sure that's true now. At least not yet. [Post edited 22 Nov 17:22]
|  | |  |
| Best squad in years. on 17:31 - Nov 22 | JamesB1979 |
| Best squad in years. on 17:12 - Nov 22 by DannytheR | It's an interesting one. Absolutely wouldn't dispute the squad depth is better than it has been for donkey's years. At the risk of nitpicking, though, I'd also say we've had an unusual amount of money available because of the Eze sell-on. (Which we've spent smartly.) And we've also needed the squad more than in the past, because for whatever reason, our injury record has been worse than at any point in recent memory. I suppose the wider question is how much a squad is about depth and how much the quality of the key players. Because that first pre-Covid Warburton team had Chair/Osayi Samuel/Eze/Wells as the front four, and I think the only one of the current forwards as good as that is still Chair! (I like Burrell and Kone but Wells was better than either, Poku is about on a level with BOS but the latter never got injured, and Eze was Eze.) And then with the later Warbs team, again, you had the best versions of Dieng, Dickie and Barbet, Illy and Willock on fire, a fit and motivated Johansen and Austin. (That Rangers vs this one would be a genuinely interesting game.) Anyway, as I say, wasn't disputing the original post as much as agreeing with Antii's that we still feel some way from the finished article. The squad feels deeper now for sure, and we seem solid in a way we haven't for a long time. But there were also times (however fleeting) under Warburton and even Beale when you'd have backed us to turn anyone over in the league, and I'm not sure that's true now. At least not yet. [Post edited 22 Nov 17:22]
|
Yeah agree on that front 4. And it is difficult to judge given the Covid disruption but we finished 13th. Looking at the midfield defence, think Kamara, Madsen, Edwards, JCS, Dunne, Cirkin, Kemper and Charles are significant improvement. I liked Barbet and Wallace but for me overall 1st team is better. And squad is a lot better. |  | |  |
| Best squad in years. on 17:41 - Nov 22 | EuroRanger |
| Best squad in years. on 17:31 - Nov 22 by JamesB1979 | Yeah agree on that front 4. And it is difficult to judge given the Covid disruption but we finished 13th. Looking at the midfield defence, think Kamara, Madsen, Edwards, JCS, Dunne, Cirkin, Kemper and Charles are significant improvement. I liked Barbet and Wallace but for me overall 1st team is better. And squad is a lot better. |
I actually disagree a little on that front four - I think there might be some rose-tinted glasses about Wells. I’d rather have Burrell (when he’s fit), personally. |  | |  |
| Best squad in years. on 19:03 - Nov 22 | derbyhoop | It's something when you take off Madsen, Chair and Smyth to bring on Dembele, Varane and Poku. |  |
| "Travel is fatal to prejudice, bigotry and narrow-mindedness, and many of our people need it sorely on these accounts. Broad, wholesome, charitable views of men and things cannot be acquired by vegetating in one little corner of the Earth all one's lifetime." (Mark Twain)
Find me on twitter @derbyhoop and now on Bluesky |
|  |
| |