| Next Manager Thread 11:28 - Nov 17 with 22650 views | DoubeDoube | Anyone in the picture? Someone mentioned Pablo Hernandez... Probably someone we have never heard of i expect. |  | | |  |
| Next Manager Thread on 10:47 - Nov 19 | Whiterockin |
| Next Manager Thread on 10:29 - Nov 19 by dna | Fav with the bookies (Mousinho) [Post edited 19 Nov 10:31]
|
I have heard Andrew Crofts mentioned a couple of times, I had to look him up as I have never heard of him. Jamestown link? |  | |  |
| Next Manager Thread on 11:10 - Nov 19 | RodgerTheDodger | We have a temporary management team in place. If they win games (and I think the players we have can beat anyone in this league) then why look for yet another Messiah? I am so sick of journeyman Messiahs in football management. [Post edited 19 Nov 11:13]
|  | |  |
| Next Manager Thread on 11:49 - Nov 19 | PawelAbbott |
| Next Manager Thread on 11:10 - Nov 19 by RodgerTheDodger | We have a temporary management team in place. If they win games (and I think the players we have can beat anyone in this league) then why look for yet another Messiah? I am so sick of journeyman Messiahs in football management. [Post edited 19 Nov 11:13]
|
Matos was not the Messiah, he was a very naughty boy |  | |  |
| Next Manager Thread on 12:05 - Nov 19 | Rhonnda_Jack |
| Next Manager Thread on 10:29 - Nov 19 by dna | Fav with the bookies (Mousinho) [Post edited 19 Nov 10:31]
|
He wasn’t even on the list yesterday. I literally have no source but google ai come to the conclusion that it would either be him or derbys boss. For he record 🫡 Silence speaks a thousand words. |  |
|  |
| Next Manager Thread on 12:10 - Nov 19 | Thornburyswan |
| Next Manager Thread on 10:47 - Nov 19 by Whiterockin | I have heard Andrew Crofts mentioned a couple of times, I had to look him up as I have never heard of him. Jamestown link? |
Into 5th fave with the bookies at 8s but biggest mover today so far is Tommy Elphick into 5/2 second favourite (was out at 33s 48 hours ago). |  | |  |
| Next Manager Thread on 12:26 - Nov 19 | raynor94 | Elphick would be my choice highly regarded by Iraola at Bournemouth and now Liverpool |  |
|  |
| Next Manager Thread on 12:35 - Nov 19 | dna |
| Next Manager Thread on 12:05 - Nov 19 by Rhonnda_Jack | He wasn’t even on the list yesterday. I literally have no source but google ai come to the conclusion that it would either be him or derbys boss. For he record 🫡 Silence speaks a thousand words. |
Think someone on here (Keith??) mentioned, earlier this week, that a championship manager had been spoken to and hadn't said no |  | |  | Login to get fewer ads
| Next Manager Thread on 13:36 - Nov 19 | jack247 |
| Next Manager Thread on 11:10 - Nov 19 by RodgerTheDodger | We have a temporary management team in place. If they win games (and I think the players we have can beat anyone in this league) then why look for yet another Messiah? I am so sick of journeyman Messiahs in football management. [Post edited 19 Nov 11:13]
|
We’ve got to be careful with this IMO, particularly if we beat Cardiff. They are all very popular and there will be a clamour to give them the job permanently. I think there’s a decent chance they’ll give us a shot in the arm over the first couple of games, but we need to appoint the best man for the job and being a former player shouldn’t come into it. So many examples of clubs falling into that trap and it going wrong when the initial bounce wears off. |  | |  |
| Next Manager Thread on 13:39 - Nov 19 | Whiterockin |
| Next Manager Thread on 13:36 - Nov 19 by jack247 | We’ve got to be careful with this IMO, particularly if we beat Cardiff. They are all very popular and there will be a clamour to give them the job permanently. I think there’s a decent chance they’ll give us a shot in the arm over the first couple of games, but we need to appoint the best man for the job and being a former player shouldn’t come into it. So many examples of clubs falling into that trap and it going wrong when the initial bounce wears off. |
If we win the three (very unlikely) I still wouldn't consider them for the position permanently. |  | |  |
| Next Manager Thread on 13:44 - Nov 19 | jack247 |
| Next Manager Thread on 13:39 - Nov 19 by Whiterockin | If we win the three (very unlikely) I still wouldn't consider them for the position permanently. |
No, but there will be a massive clamour for that, particularly on social media. Just something to be careful of. |  | |  |
| Next Manager Thread on 13:57 - Nov 19 | OptimisticJack | I'm surprised that so little has been said about Roberto being linked. Currently out of work. |  |
|  |
| Next Manager Thread on 14:18 - Nov 19 | union_jack |
| Next Manager Thread on 13:44 - Nov 19 by jack247 | No, but there will be a massive clamour for that, particularly on social media. Just something to be careful of. |
Undoubtedly. Probably those who said we shouldn’t have got rid of Martin and would have him back in a heartbeat 😏. But I don’t think the club have contemplated that nor would they. I think we’ve moved on from the sentimental and / or cheap appointment and will look for a candidate who can genuinely put us in a strong position for promotion, whether that be this season or next. |  |
|  |
| Next Manager Thread on 14:45 - Nov 19 | RichardO |
| Next Manager Thread on 14:18 - Nov 19 by union_jack | Undoubtedly. Probably those who said we shouldn’t have got rid of Martin and would have him back in a heartbeat 😏. But I don’t think the club have contemplated that nor would they. I think we’ve moved on from the sentimental and / or cheap appointment and will look for a candidate who can genuinely put us in a strong position for promotion, whether that be this season or next. |
Martin had the opportunity to stay a d prove himself given a run of good results when he had changed his tactics after his dismay run. He jumped ship with a year left on his contract while an offer was on the table from others not trusting himself to carry on a good run at the start of the season with us, if he didn't start the season well his creditable would have been called into account a lot earlier in his career by others. Were some starting to doubt Matos? |  | |  |
| Next Manager Thread on 16:54 - Nov 19 | TheAlpineShrew | Who was if on here that named Matos when all others were certain that Kim Hellberg was taking charge? I seem to remember a post with just his name on it. |  | |  |
| Next Manager Thread on 17:03 - Nov 19 | Whiterockin |
| Next Manager Thread on 16:54 - Nov 19 by TheAlpineShrew | Who was if on here that named Matos when all others were certain that Kim Hellberg was taking charge? I seem to remember a post with just his name on it. |
Ferry jack I think. |  | |  |
| Next Manager Thread on 18:33 - Nov 19 | max936 |
| Next Manager Thread on 11:10 - Nov 19 by RodgerTheDodger | We have a temporary management team in place. If they win games (and I think the players we have can beat anyone in this league) then why look for yet another Messiah? I am so sick of journeyman Messiahs in football management. [Post edited 19 Nov 11:13]
|
Great point that, not sure that its the best plan though, those 4 have seen it all at SCFC though. |  | |  |
| Next Manager Thread on 19:04 - Nov 19 | union_jack | A rumour going around that Stephen Presley has been linked to the job. |  |
|  |
| Next Manager Thread on 23:19 - Nov 19 | majorraglan |
| Next Manager Thread on 09:25 - Nov 19 by Whiterockin | His stock was the highest it could possibly be without actually taking us up. The last month has shown him how fragile our squad is when hit with injuries. He decided to cash in, I would have done the same. |
Agreed. I was on my way to the Wales match when I heard Matos was offski. I’m disappointed he’s going because I thought he was doing a good job and was the best managerial appointment the club have made in a number of years. Football is a game of little loyalty, whether that’s players or managers to clubs or vice versa. If another club has turned his head as disappointing as it is, it’s time for him to move on. Taking the emotion out of it and applying cold logic, it’s a no brainer. Matos has been given an opportunity to work at Strasbourg who are part of the Chelsea organisation, the latter are in the top 10 of the worlds richest football clubs, he’s going to have a big pay rise, get to work with better players, higher profile which may in turn lead to even better opportunities. I’d rather him gone than be disgruntled and disaffected, the king is dead long live the new king! |  | |  |
| Next Manager Thread on 07:57 - Nov 20 | RodgerTheDodger |
| Next Manager Thread on 18:33 - Nov 19 by max936 | Great point that, not sure that its the best plan though, those 4 have seen it all at SCFC though. |
It's a serious point though. Football philosophies came to dominate football management with tika-taca at Barcelona, although you could argue that the Brazilian flat back four from 1962 and its feed through a fast moving mid-field was first. We have had a series of 'philosophy' based managers, Martnez, Rodgers, Potter, Martin, Williams and Matos - with steadily (not linearly) diminishing returns. Perhaps the day of the philosophy based manager is gone if clubs now understand that every fixed view of the game has a counter and they just have to apply the counter. Which may mean that approach to management no longer works. In that case, having a management team with wide experience of different styles of play and a willingness to thread together an approach individually tailored to the specific opposition to un-stitch them might be good. It's what Paisley did at Liverpool. And a bit of loyalty might be nice. Loyalty? Everyone is loyal to their youth. |  | |  |
| Next Manager Thread on 08:42 - Nov 20 | max936 |
| Next Manager Thread on 07:57 - Nov 20 by RodgerTheDodger | It's a serious point though. Football philosophies came to dominate football management with tika-taca at Barcelona, although you could argue that the Brazilian flat back four from 1962 and its feed through a fast moving mid-field was first. We have had a series of 'philosophy' based managers, Martnez, Rodgers, Potter, Martin, Williams and Matos - with steadily (not linearly) diminishing returns. Perhaps the day of the philosophy based manager is gone if clubs now understand that every fixed view of the game has a counter and they just have to apply the counter. Which may mean that approach to management no longer works. In that case, having a management team with wide experience of different styles of play and a willingness to thread together an approach individually tailored to the specific opposition to un-stitch them might be good. It's what Paisley did at Liverpool. And a bit of loyalty might be nice. Loyalty? Everyone is loyal to their youth. |
Not gonna disagree with any of that, good post |  | |  |
| Next Manager Thread on 09:24 - Nov 20 | Daggyjack | Whiterockin said "I have heard Andrew Crofts mentioned a couple of times, I had to look him up as I have never heard of him. Jamestown link?" He played for Wales!! [Post edited 20 Nov 9:26]
|  | |  |
| Next Manager Thread on 09:53 - Nov 20 | sons_of_omri | Regarding Ash and co - never ruin a great legacy. They are heroes for stepping in but I don’t think any of them really want a managers job. |  | |  |
| Next Manager Thread on 10:26 - Nov 20 | PawelAbbott |
| Next Manager Thread on 23:19 - Nov 19 by majorraglan | Agreed. I was on my way to the Wales match when I heard Matos was offski. I’m disappointed he’s going because I thought he was doing a good job and was the best managerial appointment the club have made in a number of years. Football is a game of little loyalty, whether that’s players or managers to clubs or vice versa. If another club has turned his head as disappointing as it is, it’s time for him to move on. Taking the emotion out of it and applying cold logic, it’s a no brainer. Matos has been given an opportunity to work at Strasbourg who are part of the Chelsea organisation, the latter are in the top 10 of the worlds richest football clubs, he’s going to have a big pay rise, get to work with better players, higher profile which may in turn lead to even better opportunities. I’d rather him gone than be disgruntled and disaffected, the king is dead long live the new king! |
Rosenior had done a half decent job at Strasbourg and then got the Chelsea job for a brief period. But, that brief period probably made him rich enough to not have to worry about money ever again. |  | |  |
| Next Manager Thread on 12:01 - Nov 20 | Rhonnda_Jack |
| Next Manager Thread on 12:35 - Nov 19 by dna | Think someone on here (Keith??) mentioned, earlier this week, that a championship manager had been spoken to and hadn't said no |
To be fair that was included in the math with ai. As even AI states the Indy |  |
|  |
| |